The Minnesota State Fair and criminal justice system are more related than you think


What’s the correlation between the Minnesota State Fair and fairness in the criminal justice system?

As fairgoers begin the day with excitement and energy around the Great Minnesota Get-Together, it is critical that we acknowledge how the State Fair has always been a place of oppression for people of color. The Minnesota Territory ran its first territorial fair in 1854. The 1857 census shows fewer than 100 black residents in Minneapolis and St. Paul combined. The fair became the state fair in 1859, one year after Minnesota’s statehood. It has taken place in 151 of the 156 subsequent years, only being canceled for reasons such as war and polio outbreaks.

State fairs across the country have had widespread recent issues concerning racism and police brutality. At the 2013 Missouri State Fair, a guest likened the atmosphere to “a Klan rally” and the Missouri State Fair Commission described it as “unacceptable” when a clown wearing an Obama mask and with a broom coming from his backside was chased by a bull and told to stay still while the crowd cheered.

At this year’s Alaska State Fair, an invited rap duo from Fairbanks had their power cut and were ejected for rapping the “family friendly” set they had been invited to perform. Many other entertainers canceled in response.

Most tragically, 14-year-old Andrew Joseph III was killed during the 2014 Florida State Fair, nearly 100 youth were ejected by deputies for “unruliness” and dropped off by authorities miles away with no way to get home, no contact with parents and no monitoring whatsoever. Ironically enough, they have a section at the fair called Cracker Country, where they have youth of color pose as slaves to work off community service hours.

This year, the Minnesota State Fair will need to grapple with the fact that a 33-year-old Black man took his last breath just steps from the fairgrounds. Of the 80 full-time state fair workers, how many will acknowledge what happened to him? Of the 400 seasonal workers, how many will acknowledge an officer took his life? Of the nearly 2,700 state fair employees, how many will have Philando on their hearts or minds?

While you go from booth to booth, just know that Philando Castile was killed mere feet away from where you plan to create memories. He was murdered by Officer Jeronimo Yanez, (employed by the department contracted to patrol Falcon Heights, home of the fair) where you will enjoy live music and fried food. While you prepare to be greeted by hundreds of line workers and hosts, please remember that Philando Castile will never be able to greet his students before their school meal again. As you hustle to find parking, be mindful that Philando’s last parking spot was on Larpenteur Avenue. While you enjoy the amazing attractions, just know that a man was killed on those grounds and he may not receive justice. Does the Minnesota State Fair care about fairness in the criminal justice system? Not at all.

Read more pieces like this by Rachel Wannarka and Jason Sole on the Jim Crow North blog.

7 thoughts on “The Minnesota State Fair and criminal justice system are more related than you think

  1. I’m really surprised by this piece, at least it’s being the headline piece for the day. This is such a nonsequitur, and demeans Philando Castile’s death. It’s horrifying to read about what happens at the Florida state fair, but to make that the equivalent of merely holding an event near to where a murder occurred, well, this is strange journalism indeed.

    • You live on Native soil. Is that too strange for you? The piece is asking people to consider the multilayered intersectionality of oppression and the land we are on and the spaces we claim.

      • Who is the audience for an entry which uses language such as “multilayered intersectionality of oppression”? Except in a graduate seminar, wouldn’t language with less social science jargon make more sense.

  2. So…. what is the connection of the MN State Fair to Philandrio Castile’s death? Other than the fact that the incident occured on a street that boarders the fair grounds this piece offers no credible connection of the fair to Castile that I can see. It sounds like the authors are deeply upset and hurting about what happened to Castile and what has happened to others around the country. I understand and accept that, but if they really believe that the MN State Fair doesn’t care about the criminal justice system, they might better help their cause with direct evidenve that actually supports this contention.

  3. Upsetting things have happened at other state fairs. Upsetting, racist crimes could happen at our fair. But these do not add up to the headline or the article’s conclusion.

    Potentially of interest but also irrelevant to the headline’s premise: the Fair allows Philando’s Peace Garden (a spontaneous memorial that continues to flourish) to reside on Fair property, on Larpenteur at Fry. Some people are planning for a more permanent memorial there.

  4. I have to echo the disappointment felt in reading this piece. The subject/title implies there will be valid and concrete reasons to end the patronization of the “Great MN Get Together,” however these things never surfaced. It is good to see people still championing the movement for racial equity in social justice matters… but trying to marry this connection between Philando and The MN State fair is a reach.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.