Soccer field vs. linden tree in South Minneapolis


Plans are moving fast at Stewart Park to install a 60 X 40 yard soccer field for youth games.  Minneapolis Parks and Recreation has received $225,000 in funding from the Hennepin County Youth Sports Grant for the project, according an invitation for a community meeting held last week.  

Discussion and criticism was discouraged at the meeting on June 10, but some neighbors voiced their concerns anyway.  Among the criticisms include questioning why the field must be fenced off, which would prevent usage when the park is closed, why trees must be cut down (in particular a 40 inch in diameter Linden Tree which is said to be the oldest in the city


Courageous linden tree fights for survival
excerpted from posting by Charley Underwood in E-Democracy forum – click here for full posting

Last night I went to my first meeting of the Minneapolis Tree Advisory Commission, as a visitor and not yet a member.  Interesting doesn’t begin to describe the meeting.

The most shocking news was that the Parks and Rec Department is planning on cutting down the oldest linden tree in the city, and for no particularly good reason.

The tree, 40 inches in diameter, is located at Stewart Park, which is on the corner of 27th Street and 12th Avenue.

Is the tree diseased?  No, it is quite healthy.

Does it pose some public danger?  Not at all.

They why is the Parks Forestry Department being ordered to chop it down? Because someone wants to replace it with artificial turf.  For a soccer field. So that the kickback money that taxpayers have given to the new baseball stadium can be spent quickly.

Now you might think that this story is about a conflict between trees and soccer players.  But that is not at all the case.  The normal size of soccer field would fit quite nicely into the space available with no damage to the historic tree.  But apparently “it has been decided” that the park needs an unnecessarily oversized field and that the tree must go.

Normally, neighborhood and forestry department consultations would take place as part of the decision-making process.  But, since the money is coming from an outside source that wants to spend it quickly and without the usual oversight, the normal procedures do not apply.  “It has been decided.”  And the tree be damned. …

You can find your Parks commissioner at Be nice. They are good people. They just need to be reminded.

Parks and Recreation District Manager Obie Kipper said that the planners were on a tight time frame, so there wasn’t much time for discussion about the new field’s design.  “We’ve made our decision about the size, and about where it’s going to go,” Kipper said.  He said the parks needed to move forward with the project in order to utilize the grant money.  “If we don’t get this done, if we procrastinate, they’ll give [the money] to another field.” 

However, some people at the meeting voiced concern about the location of the field, which since it is at the far end of the park from the nearby Anderson Elementary School, would be too far to walk for the school’s physical education classes (timing being an issue). 

Others at the meeting were concerned about the trees that would be cut down.  “People love to sit under the trees and watch the game,” said one attendant of the meeting.   The trees presented a safety concern, according to Kipper, and would be problematic in the maintenance of the field’s new artificial turf.  A recent posting on the Minneapolis Issues Forum also shows concern that the oldest linden tree in the city would be cut down to make room for the new field.  

The fence around the field, which would be built for safety purposes, would mean limited access to the field when the park is closed.  Some neighbors were  worried this would prevent usage by neighbors wanting to use the park on a non-scheduled basis for pick-up games of ultimate Frisbee and other activities.

The field’s use would be primarily for park-run youth soccer leagues, which would get priority in scheduling. Rosi Cruz, who is with East Midtown Phillips Youth (EMPY) said that the park-run league doesn’t work for many immigrant youth because it requires kids to play games at parks around the city. Lack of transportation was a reason that Cruz founded EMPY, an indoor soccer league that remains at the same location.  “We were the ones that started all this, and they never thanked us,” Cruz said, referring to the 500 postcards sent to Park Commissioner Scott Vreeland pleading for more soccer fields.