Is national media coverage of Cedar Riverside fire connected to scrutiny of Somali Americans?

I woke up Tuesday morning to Facebook posts from my Somali American friends expressing their sadness and confusion about the Cedar Riverside apartment fire that day. The fire left 14 injured, destroyed a halal market, and also partially damaged a nearby mosque. Many of my friends and acquaintances were in disbelief and shock at the news as the new year began.

I also noticed national and international media (CNN, The Guardian, NY Daily News) covered the fire as well, and my first question was: Why? Neighborhood fires happen all the time; what is the national peg of a Twin Cities fire? I am not trying to take away from this tragedy, but, I’m sure there are many tragedies that have killed or injured more people or caused far more damage, but have not made it to national news. So, what is so special about the Cedar Riverside fire?

When I interviewed Burhan Mohumed, a Somali American and Cedar Riverside resident, he said he thinks it has to do with the increased national media scrutiny on his neighborhood since Al Shabab’s Nairobi mall attack in September last year.

“It’s a fall out from all the connections they tried to make in the past couple of months with Cedar Riverside [and Al Shabab’s recent mall attack in Nairobi],” he said. “So every little move and happening in this neighborhood is now being paid a whole lot of attention to.”

He continued: “If you look at how much [media] coverage we’ve been getting... we’re getting used to how much attention is put on us.”

“It is sort of a big deal in that people were hurt and jumping out the windows. But, I’m sure fires happen all over the country and they don’t get this much attention; they’re not under that media scrutiny,” he said.

To Mohumed and others in the Minneapolis community, the fire is a tragedy. The Somali community here is mourning. Yet, Mohumed said he saw tweets within hours of the fire from at least one media personality on twitter who tried to make connections between the fire and Al Shabab’s attack on Jazeera hotel in Mogadishu the same day.

Tweets like that, during a sad time like this, are racist, Islamophobic, and unfounded, according to Mohumed.

“He’s not the only one. I know, in the future, people are going to start coming out of the woodworks [and reach to make connections],” Mohumed said. “Personally, I don’t feel safe [with the scrutiny]. I’m worried, because if you keep talking about something, you will talk it into existence.”

So, what do our readers think? Are people trying to connect dots that are not there in the first place, and did national media overreact by covering the fire? Does the coverage show increased media scrutiny of Somali Americans? And, should people be worried about the Minnesota connection to terrorism in Somalia?

Or is raising this question - in this case particularly - invalid, disrespectful and borderline Islamophobic? Personally, my view is the latter. I think it is unfair and bigoted to assume the worst about a clearly grieving community during a tragedy like this.

Particularly considering that an FBI spokesperson has said, according to MPR that, "it would be sheer speculation to theorize what may have occurred here as far as any mosque or any other business in the area. So we're going to wait for the first responders to discover the facts and we'll go from there."

I agree. I say we leave the story where it’s at, and allow the Somali American community to grieve. I hope we can try to find ways to support the vibrant and bustling Cedar Riverside community to rebuild the social capital that has been lost because of this fire. And I hope people recognize that it is not fair to scapegoat an entire community based on isolated incidents. I am glad, however, that the tone of local media has been one of empathy, and not of accusation.

Coverage of issues and events that affect Central Corridor neighborhoods and communities is funded in part by a grant from Central Corridor Funders Collaborative.

POINT(114.177987 22.321702)
  • One possible reason it was covered (as have other fires in Minnesota on national news). It was very cold. Great video of icicles on the building that was buying). But I also wondered why it was covered and quickly read the CNN and ABC reports. I was pleasantly surprised that there didn't seem to be any speculation of a bomb or speculation about ties to anything except the cold weather.. I'm choosing to ignore the Lea Stramaham tweets-- he seems to be more into self promotion than journalism. - by Sheldon Mains on Sat, 01/04/2014 - 5:56pm
  • Were you bothered by CAIR MN saying immediately that it might be a 'hate crime'? I labeled my speculation as speculation. They did not. I'm glad you at least posted that I said--immediately--prayers for the victims. But as a reporter who's covered national stories from Occupy Wall Street to the Trayvon Martin verdict, I report. I don't wait until the mourning period is over because that's not what reporters do. In this case, the decision to really write about it came when the Somali car bomb attack happened on the same day, by the same group who's recruited from Minnesota. That recruitment by al Shabaab has been a nightmare for Somali parents...parents for whom I have nothing but sympathy. That's a story and so is the recent call by al Shabaab for individual jihad agains the West. Nothing I said scapegoated an entire community. The scapegoating came, as I mentioned, from CAIR. - by Lee Stranahan on Sat, 01/04/2014 - 2:35am
  • "Somali" and "Islam" aren't races therefore the comments by Lee Stranahan by definition aren't racist. "Islamophobic" is a made up word by those within Islam who prefer to redirect focus on critics of radical Islam rather than a growing minority (giving benefit of doubt its not a majority) of practitioners of Islam who support violence to achieve political domination withing any given society, including within the U.S. - by on Sat, 01/04/2014 - 2:37am
  • A building burns, and people burn in it. But what this author brings to the light is while all this is happening, there are opportunist's out there that are burning to fuel a flame that Somali-American's are trying everyday to extinguish. - by Shakur Ali on Sat, 01/04/2014 - 1:59pm
  • Aud Lind Albrecht Unfortunate gas leak? Oops, you're wrong. "Centerpoint Energy had no reports of a gas leak in the area." Here's the link to the quote from the story: - by on Mon, 01/06/2014 - 8:44am
  • Is this supposed to resemble news? There was an 'Explosion' that put 14 in the hospital and killed 3. The media MUST hate Muslims. - by Sully Bach on Sun, 01/05/2014 - 2:31pm

Our primary commenting system uses Facebook logins. If you wish to comment without having a Facebook account, please create an account on this site and log in first. If you are already a registered user, just scroll up to the log in box in the right hand column and log in.

Lolla Mohammed Nur's picture
Lolla Mohammed Nur

Lolla Mohammed Nur was Community Engagement Editor of TC Daily Planet, 2013-14.