Rents rising in Frogtown as light rail opening day approaches

The Green Line’s opening is four months away, but the train has already brought rent increases for Frogtown renters.

Organizations working closely with Frogtown have been worried about rent increases for years, and recent data from HousingLink shows that these fears may be justified.

According to Minnesota Housing Link’s third quarter analysis, median rent listings for the "shadow market" in Frogtown — duplexes, condos, single-family housing, and townhomes — have risen remarkably in the last year. In 2011, the median rent was $807. In 2012 it rose to $850, and by 2013, the median rent had jumped to $995. Rent listings for multi-unit apartment buildings have remained unchanged.

The rent increase for duplexes, condos, single-family housing, and townhomes is particularly significant for Frogtown. According to the Minnesota Housing Preservation Project (MHPP)'s Before the Train report, 43 percent of the housing in the Midway East area (which roughly corresponds to Frogtown) is single family or duplex housing. That is by far the highest percentage of single-family or duplex housing in any area along the Central Corridor. The Midway Central area has 22 percent, Midway West has 13 percent, and all other Central Corridor neighborhoods have 5 percent or less.

“We’ve heard a lot about [rent increases] anecdotally,” said Frogtown Neighborhood Association director Caty Royce. “But these numbers are huge. There’s a sense of urgency.”

Royce fears gentrification. This fear was echoed by the Minnesota Housing Preservation Project (MHPP), which released its report, Before the Train, as a means of monitoring future gentrification. The report has elaborate data on Central Corridor housing in 2011, to allow for comparison when the line opens in June. According to Before the Train, gentrification is a common phenomenon in neighborhoods with newly built transportation.

“Nationally, the experience is when transit lines go into lower income neighborhoods… rent increases are very common,” said Jack Cann, Senior Staff Attorney for MHPP.

To keep the vibrancy and diversity of the Frogtown community, the Frogtown Neighborhood Association is already brainstorming possible ways to curb gentrification.

Unanswered questions

The data shows increasing rents for single-family or duplex housing in Frogtown. It also shows that Frogtown has a lot more single-family or duplex housing than other areas. But it doesn't show what percentage of single-family or duplex housing is owner-occupied and what percentage is rental housing.

Another question is what proportion of the apartment buildings are senior housing or other housing that was built as affordable housing with limits on the rents charged.

Frogtown boundaries are also a problem for analyzing data. Each report and each agency uses different boundaries in analysis. The Before the Train report, for example, uses boundaries that are close to — but not the same as — the city's neighborhood boundaries.

“[Our goal is] to make sure [Frogtown] looks just like it does today,” said Royce. “The people who live here… call it home, and they have a right to call it home.”

One possible solution is anti-displacement vouchers. The vouchers would help subsidize costs for renters, while letting homeowners reap the benefits of increasing prices.

“We don’t want to lose neighbors,” said Royce. “[Measures] need to be put in place to maintain the wonderful diversity we have in Frogtown.”

Laura Baenen, Communications Director for the Green Line, says that the Metropolitan Council is aware of the problem, and is committed to serving the residents of Frogtown—and keeping them in the area.

“We don’t want to build a line to have customers go away,” said Baenen. “The whole point of this line was to serve a transit dependent population and to get them to jobs.”

Though Royce and her colleagues believe that the coming Green Line is the cause of rent increases, Nancy Homans, Policy Director for Mayor Coleman, says that they shouldn’t jump to conclusions.

“I think it’s hard to establish that the cause of these rent increases is entirely due to the light rail,” said Homans. “I think that any kind of investment will increase the values of the properties around it.”

According to Homans, the City’s major plan to curb gentrification is The Big Picture Project, a plan to work together with non-profits to create affordable housing.

“We’re imagining rents will go up,” said Homans. “[The Big Picture Project] is our effort around producing and maintaining affordability along the Central Corridor.”

Cann believes that the City of Saint Paul has not made a sufficient effort to thwart gentrification. Cann says Saint Paul was presented with opportunities to provide affordable housing to residents along the Green Line, but passed them by. Now, Cann says, most of the housing on the Green Line will not be affordable to lower income residents.

“I think the city has largely ignored this issue,” said Cann.

Cann believes that change will be gradual. “I certainty think that gentrification is a long term threat to all the neighborhoods along the green line, but it’s probably not going to happen… on a scale where it’s really dramatic [and fast changing],” said Cann.

As the city looks toward an opening date for the light rail line on June 14, discussions continue on how to insure that the effects of the train are not detrimental to the residents who call Frogtown home.

This is one of a number of articles produced by students at Macalester as part of a New Media class.

CORRECTION 2/27: The name of the organization providing the rental price data is HousingLink, not Minnesota Housing Link. 

POINT(114.177987 22.321702)
  • Bwhahahahahaha! I love it when Progressives get foisted on their own petard by legislating and implementing policies based purely on feel-good emotions. They have a complete inability to connect the dots of actions to consequences. - by Shelley Leeson on Thu, 02/27/2014 - 12:50pm
  • Nice job Maddie! Direct and informative....a fine journalist in the making! - by Anne Emerson on Fri, 02/28/2014 - 3:46am
  • Really appreciate the excellent reporting and balanced presentation of the issue. Amazing that this is student reporting. A complicated issue with no easy solutions. Applause to those trying to improve life for others. - by Amy Remington on Fri, 03/07/2014 - 6:05pm
  • Has consideration been made regarding the glut of short and foreclosure sales that hit the Frogtown and Midway market between 2011 and early 2013? People had previously been renting dilapidated properties which have now been flipped and greatly improved. This could easily explain the cost increase. - by Carrie Finnigan on Thu, 02/27/2014 - 8:32am
  • The chart says apartment rents are stable. The key is not whether rents for condos and single family houses go up, but whether the overall supply remains affordable for people with low incomes. Rising rates for these other properties signals rising property values, which could be a good sign for those who own homes or were renting out properties they couldn't sell. - by Charlie Quimby on Wed, 02/26/2014 - 11:45pm
  • Rents have gone up in St. Paul since 2011when we saw a low in property values. Have "shadow market" rentals gone up more in the Frogtown area than they have in neighborhoods not on the green line? Either way I think it is apparent that we need more apartment buildings - by Teresa Fisher Boardman on Thu, 02/27/2014 - 6:41am
  • Thanks to the students in the New Media Class for reporting on this. I'd love a follow up article answering some of the questions asked below by Carrie and Teresa - by Helen Duritsa on Fri, 02/28/2014 - 8:39am

Our primary commenting system uses Facebook logins. If you wish to comment without having a Facebook account, please create an account on this site and log in first. If you are already a registered user, just scroll up to the log in box in the right hand column and log in.

Maddie Gerrard's picture
Maddie Gerrard

Maddie Gerrard (email: madelinegerrard at tcdailyplanet dot net)  is a student at Macalester College. She a International Studies major with a Media and Cultural Studies minor. She is originally from Stillwater, Minnesota and currenty lives in Saint Paul.