OUR STORIES | Nancy Ford: Standing against panhandlers, counting some as friends

It was early August and Nancy Ford was on her way to work as a freelance videographer when one of the many panhandlers at the corner at 46th St. and Hiawatha Ave. started swearing at her.

“I live in the neighborhood,” she said. “I see the same people begging here day after day, year after year. I’ve been followed home. I’ve picked up their trash. I’ve found where they’ve gone the bathroom. I’d just had enough.”

Ford walked into the Walgreens, got a sharpie and made a sign. ‘Don’t give money to bums,’ it said, and she stood on the median behind the panhandler. “He was so pissed, he left behind a sandwich and a coffee from Burger King,” she said.

The sign pissed off a lot of people, she admitted. “It was very polarizing. People walking by ripped the sign out of my hands.” She changed the wording of her sign to "Don’t give money to panhandlers."

“Good advertising is immediate and effective and with a call to action,” she said.

She also got support from people driving by. “I get thumbs up. People thank me for what I’m doing. It’s fascinating. You never know what people will say to you.”

Ford says that some panhandlers may be truly needy, but with many, it’s a con. “There are enough services out there if you want to get yourself out of this situation, you can. People will sometimes give food instead of money. I find apples, bananas, granola bars – all left unopened and uneaten.”

“Some people come from the suburbs to work this corner. This is a good corner. It’s got a long light and a lot of traffic,” she said. “This isn’t easy work but this is their grind. People are creatures of habit and you’re more likely to stay with what you know than try to change.”

In the 10 to 15 hours a week Ford spends at her corner, she said she has gotten to know some of the regulars. “Most people don’t take the time to observe a public space,” she said. She admits that when she first started her campaign, she was motivated more by anger than anything else. But during her two months working alongside the panhandlers, she’s gotten to know some of them.

She said that she has had long conversations with one panhandler, a man named Mike, who puts in regular hours standing with his own sign, soliciting money from the cars that stop at the corner. “I like Gary, too. He’s real amicable. I bought him sandwiches. He’s nice, but a huge bullshitter.”

She points to a couple crossing the street. “Watch them,” she said. “They’re going to turn left and go down the bike path. They’ll smoke pot and drink Steel Reserve." (A high alcohol malt beverage in 16 oz. cans.) Sure enough, the couple turns left and wanders into the bushes.

She points to another woman. “That’s Cheryl. She lives in Eagan with her mother. She claims to have an autistic child. I’ve seen her get into her car to drive home.”

Ford gets along with most of the panhandlers, but has faced problems. “Some get on their phones to have their friends come after me," she said. Ford wears a small video camera around her neck – protection, she said. She once pepper sprayed a woman who tried to attack her.

“I’ve been thinking about doing a video, but I haven’t found the storyline yet," she said. "And, that would make me a participant, not an observer.”

“The problem of homelessness needs to be rethought. If people do this year after year, it’s not a solution,” she said. “There are resources out there, especially in this town. But, don’t ask me what to do to solve it. I’m just an observer. I’m not a social scientist. I don't have any answer, but I certainly have people talking.” Her Facebook page gives a phone number and a link to Greater Twin Cities United Way for resources and help.

Ford said that she hasn’t yet decided if she’s going to carry her fight into the winter months. “I’ll make that decision when the time comes,” she said. But, for now, she’s testing her newest sign, "Panhandler Signs. Fact or Fiction?"

Join the debate — comment below.

Related stories:

  • To those who are complaining to this woman, did you read why she is doing this? This is her neighborhood. She has to live in it. The panhandlers are driving in their cars from their homes in Eagan (for example) to panhandle in her neighborhood and making a mess in her neighborhood. And I hear "shame on you" and 'stop harassing' these people? It is legal for people to hold signs on street corners, whether it be asking for us to give them our hard earned money or whether it is in protest by someone who is tired of picking up litter, stepping over feces and finding perfectly good uneaten food tossed away by the people asking for money *in her neighborhood*. I say Good For Her! Make us think. We each contribute in our own way to this. Make us think. Thank you. - by Paula Haller on Tue, 10/01/2013 - 11:00am
  • i would note that she is protesting panhandlers, not homeless people in general. They are not the same. - by Jessica Edwards-Smith on Wed, 10/02/2013 - 2:11am
  • wow! How myopic can you be. She should be ashamed of herself. I recommend she try living the life of one of those panhandlers, try to get access to those abundant services she references. Then, she should look at the systemic issues that create this environment. - by Ryan Williams-Virden on Tue, 10/01/2013 - 9:41am
  • This is excellent! I hope I get to see you out there some day! Kudos to you for this effort! - by Gail Freedman on Mon, 09/30/2013 - 9:39pm
  • Why is this woman even getting coverage? If she wants to protest, let her protest cuts in foodstamps or the still high unemployment rate. If she thinks there is enough help available-let her find a place for these people to live tonight. The failing capitalist system leads to more poverty, more unemployment, and yes more panhandling. I give money to these folks when I can. Peter Zeftel - by Peter Zeftel on Tue, 10/01/2013 - 9:45pm
  • There are so many other larger issues that Nancy Ford can apply her time, energy and creativity towards solving. - by Katherine Werner on Mon, 10/14/2013 - 12:15pm
  • I Googled Nancy Ford since I am Nancy Ford also... but found this story that she had done... I see them all the time in my area.... I watched a Man who was grungie looking at the corner holding a sign that said .... I lost my job and have been unable to find work I have kids and a wife .. I followed this man to see what he did .... He went from the corner to a Wal Mart parking lot... so far have not been able to follow him from here but will contuinue my quest to find out if he is really out of work and has a wife and kids... being a freelancer also I am doing a story on this guy but he doesn't know it yet... way to go Nancy in your quest... - by Nancy Ford on Sun, 11/03/2013 - 11:16am
  • I understand the well-meaning protests, and yes, I have had experience with homelessness. It's horrible, and I still have nightmares. But ... how many of the readers are aware that human traffickers use their victims to panhandle? Ms. Ford is right, there ARE resources, although there could certainly be more, and those who need help need to be monitored, if not for the protection of the community, then for themselves. I speak from experience: when you're lost in the trees, you really can't see the forest. It takes people who have been trained and have access to resources to help you find your way out. And I know this from experience. - by Michele Olson on Tue, 10/01/2013 - 6:36pm
  • Nancy Ford was on her way to work WHERE as a freelance videographer? If Ms. Ford was gainfully employed as a freelance videographer she wouldn't have a lot of time to waste harassing panhandlers. - by on Tue, 10/01/2013 - 1:01am
  • Oh, and I'm not a panhandler nor am I a begger. I refuse. I have my standards. - by Greg DeadeyeCharlie Gilbert on Tue, 10/01/2013 - 9:09pm

Our primary commenting system uses Facebook logins. If you wish to comment without having a Facebook account, please create an account on this site and log in first. If you are already a registered user, just scroll up to the log in box in the right hand column and log in.

Stephanie Fox's picture
Stephanie Fox

Stephanie Fox (stephaniefox2 at tcdailyplanet dot net) has a Master's Degree in journalism from the University of Oregon. She moved to Minneapolis of her own free will in 1984.

Comments

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

As people, we choose or not

As people, we choose or not choose to give to or acknowledge panhandlers - we have our reasons when we do and we have our reasons when we don't.  I think that we are all generally intellegant enough to determine whether or not we want to do so without someone standing around "protesting" panhandling.  But we all have our causes, so I guess it is what it is.  I am well aware of how frustrating things in ones neighborhood can start to get, I deal with drug dealers, prostitutes and pimps in front of my house, waking me up nightly at 2 or 3 am on a daily basis but to me personally, panhandling pales in comparison.  It's pretty much a victimless activity unless someone is agressively panhandling which means that they are intimidating or threatening someone into giving them money.  We choose to roll our window down or to engage in speaking with someone. 

 

What I've learned from working in Human Services is that it's easier not to try to determine whether or not someone truly *needs* the thing that you are offering them if you are doing it from the heart.  There is almost always more to the story, even for the people that are using the money for things other than food or shelter.  It may be generational poverty, domestic or sexual violence, mental health or brain injury concerns that keep persons from working, long term chemical health concerns.  There is no easy solution.

We choose or not choose to

We choose or not choose to give to and/or acknowledge panhandlers - we have our reasons when we do and we have our reasons when we don't.  I think that we are all generally intellegant enough to determine whether or not we want to do so without someone standing around "protesting" panhandling.  But we all have our causes, so I guess it is what it is.  I am well aware of how frustrating things in ones neighborhood can start to get, I deal with drug dealers, prostitutes and pimps in front of my house, waking me up nightly at 2 or 3 am on a daily basis but to me personally, panhandling pales in comparison.  It's pretty much a victimless activity unless someone is agressively panhandling which means that they are intimidating or threatening someone into giving them money.  We choose to roll our window down or to engage in speaking with someone. 

 

What I've learned from working in Human Services is that it's easier not to try to determine whether or not someone truly *needs* the thing that you are offering them if you are doing it from the heart.  If you believe they are in need, then go for it.  If you feel that there might be other motivations, choose not to and don't feel guilty. 

There is almost always more to the story, even for the people that are using the money for things other than food or shelter.  It may be generational poverty, domestic or sexual violence, mental health or brain injury concerns that keep persons from working, long term chemical health concerns.  Unfortunately, there is no easy solution to homelessness, poverty and addiction - people lead their own lives and as much as we try to help or to fight their decisions, it is what it is.

...

We choose or not choose to give to and/or acknowledge panhandlers - we have our reasons when we do and we have our reasons when we don't. I think that we are all generally intellegant enough to determine whether or not we want to do so without someone standing around "protesting" panhandling. But we all have our causes, so I guess it is what it is. I am well aware of how frustrating things in ones neighborhood can start to get, I deal with drug dealers, prostitutes and pimps in front of my house, waking me up nightly at 2 or 3 am on a daily basis but to me personally, panhandling pales in comparison. It's pretty much a victimless activity unless someone is agressively panhandling which means that they are intimidating or threatening someone into giving them money. We choose to roll our window down or to engage in speaking with someone. What I've learned from working in Human Services is that it's easier not to try to determine whether or not someone truly *needs* the thing that you are offering them if you are doing it from the heart. If you believe they are in need, then go for it. If you feel that there might be other motivations, choose not to and don't feel guilty. There is almost always more to the story, even for the people that are using the money for things other than food or shelter. It may be generational poverty, domestic or sexual violence, mental health or brain injury concerns that keep persons from working, long term chemical health concerns. Unfortunately, there is no easy solution to homelessness, poverty and addiction - people lead their own lives and as much as we try to help or to fight their decisions, it is what it is.