What’s the relationship between poverty and poor decision-making?

Could it be that people of low income spend so much mental energy getting through each day that they have less capacity to deal with bigger issues that affect their lives? (Photo: Creative Commons/Mary Thompson)

Intriguing new research suggests a cause-and-effect relationship between poverty and poor decision-making.

And it’s not the connection you may think. So-called conventional wisdom, after all, has it that making poor decisions leads to reduced living circumstances.

In contrast, the research reported in the journal Science suggests that "poverty itself" reduces cognitive capacity because "poverty-related concerns consume mental resources leaving less for other tasks.''

Could it be that people of low income spend so much mental energy getting through each day balancing life’s necessities against the weight of money problems that they have less capacity to deal with bigger issues that affect their lives – issues like work, education, parenting?

Yes, suggest researchers at the University of Warwick in Coventry, England.

Consequences

Community Sketchbook focuses on the economic and social challenges facing communities, especially low-income communities and communities of color, and how people are trying to address them.

It is made possible by support from the John S. and James L. Knight Foundation, The Minneapolis Foundation, and some Minneapolis Foundation donor advisors.

Community Sketchbook articles may be republished or distributed, in print or online, with credit to MinnPost and the foundations.

The consequences are significant and measurable, they say.

From the The Guardian:

The cognitive deficit of being preoccupied with money problems was equivalent to a loss of 13 IQ points, losing an entire night's sleep or being a chronic alcoholic, according to the study. The authors say this could explain why poorer people are more likely to make mistakes or bad decisions that exacerbate their financial difficulties.

Yet there is hope of disrupting this cycle. Continuing with The Guardian:

Anandi Mani, [associate professor in economics and] a research fellow at the Centre for Competitive Advantage in the Global Economy at the University of Warwick, one of the four authors of the study, said the findings also suggest how small interventions or "nudges" at appropriate moments to help poor people access services and resources could help them break out of the poverty trap. Writing in the journal Science, Mani said that previous research has found that poor people use less preventive health care, do not stick to drug regimens, are tardier and less likely to keep appointments, are less productive workers, less attentive parents, and worse managers of their finances. "The question we therefore wanted to address is, is that a cause of poverty or a consequence of poverty?"

She said the team of researchers, which included economists and psychologists in the UK and the US, wanted to test a hypothesis: "The state of worrying where your next meal is going to come from — you have uncertain income or you have more expenses than you can manage and you have to juggle all these things and constantly being pre-occupied about putting out these fires — takes up so much of your mental bandwidth, that you have less in terms of cognitive capacity to deal with things which may not be as urgent as your immediate emergency, but which are, nevertheless, important for your benefit in the medium or longer term."”

The findings don’t surprise Nancy A. Heitzeg, sociology professor at St. Catherine University in St. Paul.

“I think poverty does have debilitating physical and mental effects,’’ she said, adding that she hopes the study can be used as a jumping-off point.

“Now that we have seen this research and we accept that as true, are we going to be able to turn to structural solutions for addressing this?’’

In other words, she’s asking is there the will in this country to change social and political policies so that the United States provides adequate services — economic, housing, food — to “minimize” poverty?

Two sets of studies

What researchers did was carry out two sets of studies, one at a shopping mall in New Jersey, the other among sugar-cane farmers in India.

At the mall, they approached about 400 people at random asking them to think about solving a hypothetical financial problem.

In an “easy” scenario, they needed a car repair that would cost $150, while in the “hard” scenario the repairs cost $1,500.

While thinking about the hypotheticals, the volunteers were tested with IQ-based puzzles and tasks measuring their attention.

The results, as Matt Yglesias writes for Slate, are revealing:

Among Americans, they found that low-income people asked to ponder an expensive car repair did worse on cognitive-function tests than low-income people asked to consider cheaper repairs or than higher-income people faced with either scenario. To study the global poor, the researchers looked at performance on cognitive tests before and after the harvest among sugarcane farmers. ….. They found that the more secure postharvest farmers performed better than the more anxious preharvest ones.

The monetary affect on cognitive skills should factor in to our understanding of poverty.

Yglesias, a business and economics correspondent, sums it up this way:

Poor people — like all people — make some bad choices. There is some evidence that poor people make more of these bad choices than the average person. This evidence can easily lead to the blithe conclusion that bad choices, rather than economic conditions, are the cause of poverty. The new research shows that this is — at least to some extent — exactly backward. It’s poverty itself (perhaps mediated by the unusually severe forms of decision fatigue tha[t] can affect the poor) that undermines judgment and leads to poor decision-making.

  • Interesting article about how poverty causes people to have reduced cognitive functioning and decision-making skills. But why are the solutions proposed always in the vein of providing more aid to the poor, instead of focusing on structural questions about why are there so many poor in this country in the first place (and why such a high proportion of the poor are brown skinned people), when we could eliminate poverty by changin the system of weath distribution and spreading around the existing resources more equitably...?? - by Nicole N Charlie MartinRogers on Thu, 09/19/2013 - 12:15pm
  • Excellent article. I'm passing it on to some people who should read it. It's easy to blame people for their individual choices, but it's more complicated. Added to what's mentioned in the article, I didn't choose to be born to middle class and educated parents who could give me financial and psychological support. I was lucky, but not everyone is so lucky. What would my life have been like if it had been otherwise? - by Stephanie Fox on Thu, 09/19/2013 - 1:16pm
  • As a person who has been pushed into poverty by the "Great Recession" I agree. The last four years have been profoundly stressful and I fear losing my home. - by Ima B. Musing on Thu, 09/19/2013 - 8:27am
  • This is a fantastic, exhaustively well-proven article. Great job! - by Rachel Lovejoy on Thu, 09/19/2013 - 6:25pm
  • What about the the cheap food with little or no nutritional value that poor people are practically forced to live on? Or our parasitic level materialistic consumerism? The entitlement mentality even? I would like to propose the theory that these are important factors contributing to and exasperating an already gargantuan problem. This article certainly makes some valid points, but it seems that the issues that it makes are merely symptoms and not causes. - by William Erickson on Thu, 09/19/2013 - 9:32pm
  • This issue speaks directly to the work done by Myles Horton + staff at Highlander School with 'poor people', decision-making, social change and democracy. Rosa Parks made a decision in choosing a particular seat on a bus after a Highlander workshop. For anyone interested read "The Long Haul", an Autobiography by Myles Horton. - by Julie Hellwich on Fri, 09/20/2013 - 9:01am
  • So, am I to believe now, that Welfare causes Mental Illness/Stress! Bunk,Bunk! People you can change your circumstances, NOT receiving Aid from Every Corner of the Government/Taxpayers! - by Michael Blevens on Thu, 09/19/2013 - 2:14pm

Our primary commenting system uses Facebook logins. If you wish to comment without having a Facebook account, please create an account on this site and log in first. If you are already a registered user, just scroll up to the log in box in the right hand column and log in.

Cynthia Boyd's picture
Cynthia Boyd

Cynthia Boyd writes Community Sketchbook for MinnPost.