Senate passes voter ID bill

Minnesota is another step closer to having a photo ID constitutional amendment on the November ballot.

The amendment, which will require people to present photo identification to vote, passed 36-30 Friday night after roughly six hours of debate in the Senate. All the “yes” votes came from Republicans. One Republican voted with every Democratic-Farmer-Labor senator in voting “no.”

Since the Senate version is slightly different from the House version that passed earlier this week, House and Senate negotiators will have to reconcile minor differences in a conference committee between the two and adopt a final version. The House could also choose to simply accept the different language in the Senate bill.

Once it clears that final hurdle, it will be go before voters in November.

Gov. Mark Dayton cannot veto a constitutional amendment.

The bill’s sponsor, Sen. Scott Newman, R-Hutchinson, said it’s necessary in order to prevent election fraud and to ensure that elections are legitimate.

Opponents said that there are few instances of voter fraud in Minnesota and that any photo ID requirement will likely disenfranchise thousands of people.

Sen. Patricia Torres Ray, DFL–Minneapolis, said the requirement will essentially end same-day voter registration, which is a popular among Minnesota voters, because the secretary of state “would not be able to verify a person’s identity fast enough to allow people to vote the same day.”

“We will have very little choice but to eliminate same-day voter registration as a result of this legislation,” Torres Ray said.

DFLers said more than 500,000 Minnesota voters used same-day registration in 2008.

Secretary of State Mark Ritchie, who oversees the states elections and opposes the photo ID requirement, has said he has concerns the amendment will kill same-day registration and the possibility for a new system of “provisional voting” will harm the state’s election system.

Provisional ballots are votes cast on election day but they’re not counted until voters make a second trip to election officials with a required government-issued ID. Provisional ballots don’t currently exist in Minnesota.

DFLers offered numerous amendments to the requirement, but none passed.

An amendment from Sen. John Howe, R-Red Wing, that would allow future legislators to use new technology for identification purposes overwhelmingly passed.

Before the Senate debate started, roughly 300 people protested the proposed amendment with signs saying, “All our voices count,” taping $1 bills over their mouths to signify their belief that corporate interests were stealing the public’s voice, and singing hymns that echoed throughout the Capitol.

Newman said the Legislature will have to take up some of the details of the bill next year.

He admitted that “some burden will be placed on our citizens,” but he remained confident that the amendment will improve Minnesota’s election system.

 “On balance, I believe this amendment is the right thing to do,” he said.

Our primary commenting system uses Facebook logins. If you wish to comment without having a Facebook account, please create an account on this site and log in first. If you are already a registered user, just scroll up to the log in box in the right hand column and log in.

Nick Sudheimer's picture
Nick Sudheimer

Nick Sudheimer writes for the Minnesota Daily.