Google+ resorts to a deceptive trick to get users to invite their friends to join

From the average user's standpoint, Google+ has been a flop. Soon after everyone joined, Google's social network turned into a ghost town as most users realized that it was basically a Facebook that was less intuitive to use, and with many fewer active users.

Google, though, is still Google, and many people who work at enterprises where search engine results drive a lot of traffic—such as, for example, news sites like the Daily Planet, where over half of all traffic typically comes from search engines—are remaining warily engaged with Google+ out of respect for Google's power to weight results. When Google calls us to the plate, we figure we'd better play ball.

Now, Google seems to be trying to trick us into recruiting our friends to play too. Take a look at the above screenshot, taken from my Google+ home page today. Would you look at that and assume that Makula Dunbar is a Google+ member already? I sure would, and I assumed the same thing about another friend whose name initially appeared below Makula's. "You may know." Well, yes, Google, you are aware that I've e-mailed these people, so you know I know them.

Hover over a name like Makula's, and here's what you see.

Google+

Any indication that Makula's not already signed up for Google+? Nope, nor was there any indication with my other friend, so I added her to my circle of friends. Some friend I turned out to be, though, when my friend received an e-mail saying, "Jay Gabler added you to his circles and invited you to join Google+."

I learned about the e-mail because she responded to me with one word: "No."

Wait, I was inviting her to join? I thought I was just adding her already active Google+ account to my circles. Life online is sometimes confusing, but there seemed to be nothing confusing about that "you may know" box. Let's call this Google+ practice what it is: deceptive.

    Jay Gabler's picture
    Jay Gabler

    Jay Gabler (jay [at] tcdailyplanet [dot] net, Twitter @JayGabler) is the Daily Planet's arts editor.

    Comments

    More deceptive than you thought

    Thank you for this excellent article. Google+ engages in an even more deceptive practice. They sent me three emails saying people I know had invited me to join Google+! They had not. That was a blatant lie. But I did not know that and "accepted" their invitations...which they quickly informed me they had not made. Then I started to get other, similarly phony invitations. I am currently not living in the US, but I think this deceptive practice merits a look from the FCC or the FTC.

    Google+

    I was so excited when Google+ "let me in" when they were allegedly not letting everyone in. When I join, I come to find that no one uses it or knows what it is, including myself. I'm irritated with it even though I love a great many google applications. Too bad they couldn't just let facebook have this one... just when the last dinosaurs (my older relatives) are finally joining facebook after my repeated requests...

    Post new comment

    The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
    • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.
    • Allowed HTML tags: <a> <em> <strong> <cite> <code> <ul> <ol> <li> <dl> <dt> <dd> <p> <br> <img> <span> <div>
    • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
    • Each email address will be obfuscated in a human readable fashion or (if JavaScript is enabled) replaced with a spamproof clickable link.

    More information about formatting options