Minneapolis » By neighborhood:
St. Paul » By neighborhood:

Site navigation

By section

SMTWTFS
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 

Little Joey Peterson may be only 10, but let me tell you: his acting stinks.

by Jay Gabler •

SteppingStone Theatre is presenting its annual holiday show, and you will read about the show in the Daily Planet. Jean Gabler (yes, my mom) will be seeing the show this Friday and she will write about it. It won’t be a “review,” though. Why? Robyn Priestley, who handles PR for the company, explained the following to me in an e-mail.

front row seat is the blog of jay gabler, the daily planet’s arts editor. to keep up on the local arts scene, follow artsorbit on twitter and subscribe to arts orbit weekly.
Due to the sensitive nature of reviewing children, SteppingStone has a policy of not allowing “reviews” per se, in that they don’t allow people to write about the children’s actual performances. The philosophy behind it is that they want to shield the kids from anything that could feel like individual criticism, call into question the performance choices, or even give one or two kids praise at the expense of others (even by omission). The guideline is that the reviewers can talk about the show in general, individual kids (insofar as they’re writing about who they are and not about their performances), SteppingStone’s mission and how they pursue it, and the new theatre, of course. I’m sure you can understand the reasoning behind this philosophy. SteppingStone is all about creating community, and expressing the creativity and potential in all the kids that come to perform and learn, without fostering the unhealthy sort of competition, jealousy and criticism that can unfortunately come into youth activities.

This is entirely understandable, but I have mixed feelings about agreeing to these terms. A principle at the heart of journalism is that no source or subject of any story—even a cute little kid—has the right to dictate the terms of coverage. As readers, you trust the Daily Planet and other news sources because you trust that we are independent, that we write only what we want to write and what we feel needs to be written.

Yes, you say, but this is different. We wouldn’t actually call out a little angel (or shepherd, or sheep) for forgetting her lines, would we? Of course we wouldn’t…but when does a young actor cross that line and ask to have his or her work taken seriously? Tatum O’Neal won an Oscar for her performance in Paper Moon when she was only 10. Should she not have been nominated, to have spared her the risk of being disappointed at losing?

Theater reviews are news, and in all our news coverage we strive to be sensitive to the age of people we write about. The juvenile justice system will generally not release the names of underage perpetrators of crimes, and as a news organization we are respectful of families’ need for privacy in such situations. We are cautious about publishing photos of, and direct quotes from, children without parental permission—particularly if the child’s full name is to be used.

A child who appears in a theatrical production open to the public, with public program credits, is—with his or her parents’ permission—openly taking credit and responsibility for his or her performance. That’s part of the fun, and part of the learning experience. After weeks of rehearsal, each member of the SteppingStone cast will stand onstage and take ownership of his or her own performance. I’m disposed to write about young actors’ performances in a manner as similar as is reasonable to the manner in which I write about adult actors’ performances—and I encourage other Daily Planet reviewers to do the same.

That said, I recognize that it would in most cases be unkind and unconstructive to single out any child as the object of critical comments. Any actor’s performance is a collaboration with the production’s director and creative team, and when that actor is a child, the director bears more responsibility than with a seasoned adult performer. I had this in mind when I wrote my recent review of The Lion, the Witch, and the Wardrobe. The Children’s Theatre Company imposed no restriction such as SteppingStone’s (granted, CTC is a professional theater company employing many adult actors, whereas SteppingStone is primarily an educational venture with casts of children), but still I declined to make specific comments on the young actors’ individual performances. I was a little more candid in private conversations with my friends, but publicly, I respected the need for discretion.

So why did I decide to accept SteppingStone’s terms? Because I was quite certain that the reviewer would not have violated those terms even in their absence—this is my mother we’re talking about, after all—and, frankly, because those terms were tied to complimentary press tickets that our budget would not otherwise have accommodated the cost of. It’s a near-universal practice for theater companies to “comp” members of the press, but normally there is no quid pro quo regarding the nature, tone, or scope of subsequent coverage. Reviews would be much less meaningful if we promised they’d all be positive, and playmakers respect that. In this case, however, I did agree that our coverage would abide by the above terms—and it’s important that you know that agreement is in place. Should it be?

Published on 12/1/08. Photos: Erin Hampe, Nathan Barlow, and Teresa Doran in The Lion, the Witch and the Wardrobe, photo by Rob Levine, courtesy CTC; Ryan and Tatum O’Neal in Paper Moon, © Paramount Pictures Corporation. The name “Joey Peterson” is not meant to refer to any actual person.

Comments

Laurel L's picture

hmm

You’re kind of a jerk. Actually, not kind of. You are. In fact the last sentence of the second to last paragraph made me laugh. Because honestly, I can’t imagine you have friends who could stand listening to your arrogant self. But I suppose, to each his own. Here’s the thing. Little kids who pursue theater are not looking to be judged. Young actors are simply pursuing a passion. If performing is something they enjoy, they have the right to do so without bitter reviewers like you passing their negative judgement to the world. I’m disappointed by many statements in your article. SteppingStone is a place for these kids to learn. It’s not professional theater, and it knows that. Anyone with one bad remark about them needs to look into their mission and what it is they do for kids. They don’t claim to be an amazing award-winning broadway-like place. They give kids the chance to do something creative. And you also imply the performances of the young actors in The Lion, the Witch, and the Wardrobe were less than ideal. Funny. I’ve seen the production, and was more than impressed with them. Actually, everyone I spoke to was. I’ve worked with a professional theater company for almost 10 years now, so I don’t say that lightly. The four main children played their roles to perfection, with such emotion and dedication, I find it truly surprising it has not been clearly brought to attention by our papers. Apparently, as proved by this article, the Twin Cities (or just the Daily Planet) are in dire need of reviewers who actually have an eye for the arts, and will give the readers a relatable article. Or at least one worth reading. For now, I guess I’ll stick to the Examiner.

Post new comment

The Twin Cities Daily Planet encourages readers to submit comments voicing their views in a constructive and civil fashion. The editors reserve the right to edit comments for length and clarity, and we may decline to publish comments that advertise services or goods, take an intemperate tone, or that contain potentially libelous allegations.
The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
CAPTCHA
This question is for testing whether you are a human visitor and to prevent automated spam submissions.
4 + 1 =
Solve this simple math problem and enter the result. E.g. for 1+3, enter 4.

News you can use

Choose your school

Saturday is School Choice Day in both Minneapolis and St. Paul. If you’re the parent of a student, you have the opportunity to send your child to either the public school in your neighborhood or a magnet school. You also have the opportunity to send your child to a charter or a private school. Both school districts, and metro-area charter schools, are planning one-stop information fairs where, they say, you can find out all you need to know about schools where you might want to send your child. MORE »

Weekend What's What 1/8-1/11: Hunt and gather

Way to bounce back! The Twin Cities seem to have easily shaken off their holiday lethargy just in time for a pretty rockin’ weekend. Art exhibits, which have been on holiday hiatus as of late, are back in full effect; while rock shows and dance parties continue to ignite flames all over town. Our suggestion? Go out on the prowl! Meet some new people, see some new sights, and experience some fresh excitement. It is 2009 after all (an excuse we’ll be using throughout January, if not February). MORE »