Welcome to America. Now spread 'em!
We have come to accept that 9/11 served as a mere pretext for implementing a wish list of far right objectives, from regime change in Iraq to sweeping new police powers to tax cuts to privatizing Social Security. To date, however, we have tended to assume that torture and “harsh interrogation techniques” were a response, even a panicky reaction to the terrorist attacks.
Personally, I’ve never thought that to be the case. The people in charge at the Bush White House represent a wing of the body politic that has long clamored for the overturn of Supreme Court decisions dating back to the 50s that, in the view of this claque, “coddle criminals.” What these folks have dreamed of now for more than a generation is a return to the days when cops felt free to take suspects into the backroom and beat confessions out of them and courts were willing to accept such coerced evidence.
No, prisoner abuse is no afterthought with these criminals. As with the wholesale privatizing of Iraq, the Bushies have introduced torture and other banned practices overseas as a backdoor route to acceptance of them on our own soil. Already, White House doublespeak and coded messaging have given law enforcement agencies at every level of American society the green light to rough up people detained for whatever reason. After all, if they weren’t criminals, they wouldn’t have been detained, right? Fortunately, most law enforcement personnel are decent, well-meaning individuals unwilling to take up the tacit invitation. But, as at Abu Ghraib, there are always going to be a few “bad apples” more than happy to follow the lead of the truly rotten apples at the top.
Consider an incident that occurred last month at Minneapolis-St. Paul International Airport. On that day, a gang of probably bored ICE (Immigration and Custom Enforcement) agents decided that a party of Finnish musicians and filmmakers here to embark on a free tour of the Upper Midwest – at the invitation of the University of Minnesota, no less — were drug smugglers, no doubt about it, based solely on the fact that the group had flown in from Amsterdam and one of their party is a long-haired male. And if not drug smugglers, then at the very least they must have been trying to sneak into the U.S. to find work without the proper visas.
The Finns’ ordeal began when they were waiting in line to clear customs. In a variation on the Shock and Awe methods so beloved by the Bush Administration, an ICE agent approached the long-haired male musician and began jabbing his finger into the poor guy’s face and screaming, “You’re a criminal! Don’t deny it! We know you’re a criminal!” The musician, whose English is limited, tried to explain what he was doing in the country, but to no avail. The agent went on with the tantrum.
Before long, the entire group was accosted by agents – eventually eight ICE agents in all were involved in the incident — all screaming and carrying on like a military patrol kicking in doors in Anbar Province. Before long the group’s luggage had been dumped in the center of the room and, while other passengers waited to get through Immigration and Customs, searched.
Failing to discover any contraband, the ICE agents – -rather than releasing the group with an apology – changed tack and decided that its real offense was to try to enter the country under false pretenses. Because the artists were not being paid to tour – the University was covering its expenses – they did not all have work visas, just passports.
For the next three and a-half hours the members of the group were separated and placed in interrogation rooms where they were screamed at, threatened with jail if they did not “confess,” and lied to by agents claiming that other members of the party had already confessed to unspecified offenses. In retaliation for claiming that he might have some legal, or at least human rights the agents were infringing upon, the ICE goons not only started bellowing “You have no rights! You have no rights” at one of the Finns but also ordered the offending fellow to strip naked and subjected him to a full-body cavity search.
The whole ordeal finally came to an end in a way that suggests the utterly haphazard nature of our border security: another international flight arrived and the ICE agents had to turn their attention elsewhere. The Finns were released without explanation or apology.
Perhaps the most damning comment on the incident was delivered by the Finn who was strip-searched. On a couple of occasions prior to 1991, he was detained by the KGB and interrogated. Compared to the ICE agents here in the Twin Cities, the KGB operatives, he says, “at least acted like human beings. Not a bunch of animals.”
Needless to say, the artists were traumatized by their experience of American hospitality. None express any interest in returning to this country for any reason. Can’t imagine why…
workaround
























Comments
Cite your sources, people! I mean, c'mon...
Broderick’s article is well-written, and as much as I’m inclined (sadly) to believe the story about the Finnish artists’ ordeal at the airport, I can’t, because I have no idea where the information came from. It could have been a dream he had for all readers know. Even most bloggers know better. I read the Daily Planet, well, daily, and I’ve come across this lack of a basic journalistic standard more than once. Writers are volunteers or are pulled from a daily agregate, I know, but still I’d like to see the Planet be a little more picky.
Cite your sources response
Though I am not paid to blog by the Daily Planet, I am one of the co-founders of the site, have some 30 years experience writing and editing publications here and elsewhere, am a graduate of the University’s School of Journalism, and the recipient of numerous awards for my work from the Minnesota Society of Professional Journalism and the Minnesota Magazine Pubishers Association, among others (you can look it up; I’m not dreaming any of this). My blog contains a quote from one of the Finns harassed by the ICE, which I think represents a form of direct sourcing, while all of the information about their ordeal came from an interview I conducted with several members of the party a week ago Sunday at the Metrodome Holiday Inn in Minneapolis. If you wish to confirm this, you may contact Jukka Savolainen, Speer Visiting Professor in Finnish Studies at the University of Minnesota. Prof. Savolainen hosted the Finnish artists, spent three and a-half hours waiting for them at MSP while they were being interrogated, and was also present when I interviewed them. If I refrained from using any of the artists’ names in the blog, it was because they requested anonymity, fearing ICE reprisals should any of them return to the U.S. in the future. Needless to say, I felt bound to honor their request.
I hope this addresses your concerns about the credibility of my reporting on this incident. Thanks for the reading the Planet. Rich
I am quite curious about
I am quite curious about what actually happened. —- There are so many Finnish musicians annually coming to tour in America. There are individuals, duets, ensembles, singers, choirs… There are folk musicians, church musicians, classical and popular musical artists… They come and delight the Finnish immigrants and the one, two or three-year Finnish-Americans. They perform at churches, halls, retirement halls, private homes and festivals. They stay at private homes. Yet, this is the first time that I have heard of anything like this. None of the artists that have come through here, the northwest, even this past year or so have had any complaints. Nothing different than what all of us have coming through customs returning from Finland or elsewhere from vacation or busness. —- So what was going on? Was there one obnoxious customs official or was there one obnoxious Finn? Certainly from the discription, there was an escalation of events, showing total lack of respect and civility. Usually in cases like that both sides forgot to take the high road and be “cool.” —- The anonimity makes me very curious as to who the group was. Certainly in this day an age it will not stay secret for very long. As a promoter of all things Finnish, I would worry about the image that the group (or maybe it was just one individual) gave and not about some particular customs official. However, if you can honestly say that you, the musician, did not in any way excalate the situation, then next time come through another port, but remind yourself, just in case, to be at all times respectful when crossing borders.
Citing Sources
I, too, was bothered by the non-sourcing, but I also wonder what about the University? Are they aware of all this? Is there not outrage, at least from the music department? What has the University done to make the event public? It seems that the U would be affected by this event, and would want to be effective toward making sure it doesn’t happen again. What did the University sponsors have to say?
Sources & indentities
mrs Chisholm – for more details, please check out a link to this article at Boing Boing: http://www.boingboing.net/2007/10/29/finnish-folk-band-fi.html
I have no reasons to doubt the comments from the distinquished artists- Especially the “long-haired-detainee” in question has a very honorable career of 30 years. His career reaches to the point where he is recognized as even somewhat of an national hero because of his heritage within Finnish pop music.
For myself – I have travelled to US many times in both business and leisure and haven’t experienced anything like this. But recognizing my homeland’s past under Soviet influence I am truly appalled by the behavior ICE agents demostrated.
Surprised?
This incident doesn’t surprise me.
America portrays itself to be this “free” place, and I feel that we have an “Our crap don’t stink” attitude. We’re constantly making it look like everybody else, but us, is the bad guy. With an experience like this, I can’t imagine those Finns having an interest in coming back.
Well-written and a great read!
Hard to Imagine
“None express any interest in returning to this country for any reason.”
Boy, that’s hard to imagine! I agree with the above post in that we need to take a long hard look at ourselves and ask is it us or is it them?!
Chris
A city on a hill.
The exchange of comments under this article will, no doubt, excite the eye-rolling of the right-wingers who will call us “blame America first-ers”. But we are not the ones who called the US “a city on a hill”. And if we are that city, we must remember that our behavior is ALWAYS under scrutiny.
For me, I’d rather remember that the US is one nation in a world of nations. There are things we do well, and there are things other do better. I suspect security is something others do better.
Post new comment