Tuesday, Feb 9, 2010
workaround

User login

Connect
Sign in using Facebook
S M T W T F S
 
1
 
2
 
3
 
4
 
5
 
6
 
7
 
8
 
9
 
10
 
11
 
12
 
13
 
14
 
15
 
16
 
17
 
18
 
19
 
20
 
21
 
22
 
23
 
24
 
25
 
26
 
27
 
28
 
 
 
 
 
 
 

workaround
view counter
view counter
view counter
view counter

Is North Minneapolis getting gentrified?

July 14, 2008
“Gentrification” is a process of neighborhood change that historically has included a strong racial component, replacing Black and low-income residents with higher income White residents. Many Black residents of North Minneapolis are expressing concern that just such a process is underway in the neighborhoods they call home.

Over the years, gentrification has occurred under such names as “urban renewal” in the 1950s and ’60s. According to an April 2001 report by the Brookings Institute and PolicyLink on gentrification, it also took place during a “back-to-the-city” movement in the late 1970s and early ’80s.

Today, gentrification is occurring in many U.S. cities as “urban redevelopment,” says National Economic and Social Rights Initiative Legal Program Director Tiffany Gardner. “There was just a redevelopment plan that was [recently] passed here by the New York City Council. The famed 125th Street, which is Harlem’s main street, is now going to have luxury high-rise condominiums.

“Once these luxury condominiums go up,” Gardner points out, “a lot of the small business owners who are service providers for the [nearby] public housing community and other poor and middle-income [residents] will be pushed out.”

Gentrification “is really impacting poor Americans across the country,” Gardner surmised. Many believe that it has been occurring for some time on Minneapolis’ North Side.

The Minneapolis City Council approved the Near Northside Master Plan in 1998. According to the City’s website, it is to create “an attractive and sustainable urban neighborhood in the Near Northside…to rebuild a mixed-income, mixed-density, culturally diverse, amenity-rich neighborhood.”

A Northside resident (name withheld by request) says he believes this master plan really means moving Blacks out and moving Whites in. His parents once lived in the 7th and Emerson area, but, according to him, they had to move because they lived near the Sumner Field public housing area slated for demolition.

“[Ten years ago] my mom sold their house for 70, 80 thousand, but now the property is worth $250,000,” he explains. Although his parents later relocated in another Northside neighborhood, “They would love to have stayed where they were,” their son added.

Ryan Companies is seeking exclusive building rights for the proposed $220 million Bassett Creek Valley development project. It includes an office complex along with an 800-unit housing development, and will be located in the Harrison neighborhood.

Ryan Vice President Rick Collins says that almost half of the 800 units will be “affordable,” but “because we are not a housing developer, we really have to wait to involve other housing developers,” he adds.

Local activist Bill English, in a recent published article, accused Minneapolis Mayor R.T. Rybak of promoting gentrification through the Minneapolis Advantage Loan Program that began in April, which offers a $10,000 zero-percent interest loan that is forgivable in five years to anyone buying a home in key neighborhoods in the city.

English was quoted, saying, “The goal seems to be, to get rid of the poor people, to regentrify the community.”

That is wrong, says Rybak spokesman Matt Laible. Our attempts to contact English and clarify his statement were unsuccessful.

Over 600 loan applications were distributed for the Advantage Loan Program, says Community Planning and Economic Development Department (CPED) spokesperson Krista Bergert, adding that the program is now closed. Twenty-two loans were closed, with 28 others remaining in “reserve” status, meaning that they either are in the process of being closed or other factors are pending. One applicant is on a waiting list, according to Bergert.

Hennepin County commissioners in June voted to allocate as much as $1.25 million for demolition of 50 abandoned homes in Minneapolis. Commissioner Mike Opat, who introduced the plan, says this isn’t gentrification but “a clean-up effort” because 544 vacant homes are located in his district, which lies in North Minneapolis. “We are talking about houses that are sitting there, where half the buildings have been burned,” notes Opat.

Hennepin County Commissioner Peter McLaughlin adds, “We don’t want to be gentrifying neighborhoods, but we want to make them places where people of all incomes can live.”

Ethylon (E.B.) Brown believes that the “demise of the housing project on Olson [Memorial Highway]” due to the Hollman Consent Decree of the late 1990s began the Northside gentrification process. Brown, director of the Oasis of Love crisis intervention program, recalls once getting a phone call in 2000 from “an older woman who lived in her home for over 20 years and was very active in her [Greenway] community.

“She was calling me in tears,” Brown says, “asking, ‘Is there anyone who can help me? I am being forced to move out.’ She was given an amount of money to vacate her home, one of those old-style Tudor homes. She raised her family there, and it was bulldozed.

“I understood that she didn’t have a voice,” continues Brown. “I didn’t feel the ability to go and help her fight [what happened]. I could hear it in her voice that her heart was broken.”

Mrs. Nellie Campbell and her late husband moved from Texas to the North Side in 1977. “This is so close to downtown,” she says of their home’s location, but she is concerned about how her neighborhood is changing due to the growing number of vacant houses.

“Now we have a lot of houses that’s empty,” Campbell notes. “I soon will be 80, but my kids feel that [the neighborhood] is unsafe, and they don’t want me to live here. But I am going to stay here until I can’t take care of myself. I got good neighbors on both sides of me, and good neighbors across the street from me. I feel comfortable.”

Is gentrification also claiming schools on the North Side? Minneapolis Public Schools (MPS) have closed some neighborhood schools due to low enrollment, and some believe North High School could be next.

“We are committed to supporting North High and boosting its enrollment,” MPS Superintendent Bill Green says in a released statement, dispelling rumors of North High closing its doors. “The district’s administration team recognizes the importance of North High in the North Minneapolis community and the district as a whole.” (See Green’s complete statement on this week’s Opinion/Commentary page.)

Brown says she is worried that the current redevelopment in the area is not for Black Northside residents, but instead for others. There are too many developers “from the outside, and they have a view of how they want the city to be,” she points out. “I need to know what the plan of the development is, and they are not always developers that start from the inner city.”

Finally, Brown urges community residents to speak out against gentrification. It is “a fast pace that is occurring in our neighborhoods and how they are rapidly changing.

“We want our North Minneapolis to look like North Minneapolis, and not to look like first-, second- and third-ring suburbs,” Brown says.

Charles Hallman welcomes reader responses to challman@spokesman-recorder.com, or read his blog: www.ww wchallman.blogspot.com.

Comments

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

Current northside residents

Current northside residents have no cause to complain about so-called gentrification. As a northsider, I would love to see more of my neighbors convert from renters to homeowners. With houses selling at 1990 values ($25k for a 2-bedroom house!), buying is cheaper than renting and there is no cause for anyone to leave. Deadbeats, gang-bangers, and drug-dealers, however, may be pushed out. To which I say good ridance.

What did the north side look like in the 1920's, 1930's, etc?

It looked a lot different, as did Hennepin Ave. Long before that, what is now St. Anthony Falls looked MUCH different. Get over it.

Gentrification

So, they would rather keep the housing stock in falling down condition?

God speed gentrication

If "gentrification" means getting rid of open air drug dealing and empty buildings falling down on themselves, then I say "bring on the gentrication." It's a little early to be concerned about anybody getting displaced. It's not like anybody is living in the empty buildings, so who is getting displaced? Nobody. Well, except for a few crackhead squatters who live in empty buildings and shit in toilets without the plumbing hooked up.

The north side

Who decides what's right for the north side? Government agencies, "activists", private businesses, current residents, old time residents? It's hard to say. My dad grew up on the north side and went to North High. Back then it was mostly a Catholic and Jewish neighborhood. I went to Bremer and Ascension, and my brother and sisters all went to North high or Henry high. We're old time northsiders and back in the 70's it was still a majority white area with an increasing black population. A lot of the new residents moved to the north side from Detroit, Flint, St. Louis, Chicago, etc. People kept coming because Minneapolis offered a better life and more opportunites. My friends little brothers and sisters who were 4 or 5 years younger than us were often one of only 2 or 3 whites in their class. The first Hmongs started moving to the North side in the early 80's. We had no say in the changing demographics at that time, and I don't really think we deserved one because people were coming here to improve their lives. Do I think the current changes are bad? No. I say make the north side better. Having a strong inner city will help the metro area as a whole. A concentration of people on the lower economic scale doesn't help anyone. A mixed economic demographic helps the whole community and there can be a positive influence across the different econmic classes. That's what the north side needs. Can the Minneapolis media and government have the courage to toss pathological political correctness to say and do what needs to be done is the biggest question. I doubt it. I just hope all the voices are heard and not just the so called "activists" from the north side who should have no more say than my family or any other. It's time for Minneapolis to be selfish and do what's right for the city. Make the north side livable again, and have the guts to stand up to people who use self-rightiousness, an undeserved sense of entitlement, and use racial polarization as a weapon to keep their high profile. Let common sense rule for once for the benefit of residents of all races and ethnic groups.

Good Grief

It's almost funny reading this article just one year after it was written. Gentrification? I wish! I have two vacant homes across the street from me, plunging home value, drug dealing at the business behind my house, a chronic issue with illegal garbage dumpers in my alley, vacant store fronts up and down West Broadway. I don't think Mr. Hallman is in touch with reality on the Northside. Gentrification was not occuring in July 2008, and it is definitely not occuring now. Any development you might see here and there on Broadway or in the neighborhoods is funded by non-profits or the government. I hope that the private investments that drive "gentrification" are on their way to North, but right now NOMI has nothing in common with the condos going up in Harlem. We'd be lucky just to fill all of the vacant houses with residents and the vacant store fronts with legitimate business. There is still PLENTY of room for everyone on the Northside. We need political activism that is PRO-development, not oddly resistant. I'm more concerned about avoiding the fate of Detroit than that of Manhattan.

Post new comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.
  • Allowed HTML tags: <a> <em> <strong> <cite> <code> <ul> <ol> <li> <dl> <dt> <dd> <p> <br> <img> <span> <div>
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.

More information about formatting options

view counter
workaround
view counter

Related content

Free Speech Zone

The Free Speech Zone offers a space for contributions from readers, without editing by the TC Daily Planet. This is an open forum for articles that otherwise might not find a place for publication, including news articles, opinion columns, and announcements.

Have you used SeeClickFix? Have you gotten any response from city officials? Let us know - email info@tcdailyplanet.net

Click below to report a problem, or to see more detailed reports from your zip code, city or neighborhood. Minneapolis 311 and the St. Paul mayor's office in St. Paul monitor SeeClickFix.

Minneapolis
St. Paul
Other