Minneapolis »

By neighborhood:

St. Paul »

By neighborhood:

Students shine green light on garbage burner

February 23, 2008

Starting in April 2010, Minnesota Twins fans for the first time in decades will get to experience the sights of outdoor baseball.

The open sky, pennants rippling in the breeze, the natural green grass, and … the smokestacks of a giant garbage incinerator?

The Hennepin County Energy Recovery Center, or HERC, is a just a long foul ball from the new stadium site. The facility burns household trash to power steam turbines, which generate electricity for about 26,000 homes. Most of what comes out of the smokestacks is steam, an official said, and the emissions don’t pose a health risk to fans.

The county, the University of Minnesota’s College of Design, and a student group called Greenlight are working together to educate the public about the HERC, as well as brainstorm ways to spiff up its appearance a bit before fans by the thousands start descending on the site 82 days a year.

The burner is co-owned by the county and a company called Covanta Energy Corporation, which owns and operates waste-to-energy power plants around the world.

“We need to respond to real concerns, not preconceptions,” said Sarah Wolbert, a member of Greenlight, an organization for aspiring architects.

The group’s suggestions don’t result in a total body make-over, but they think it might be enough to improve perceptions of the plant. Its ideas are aesthetic and functional. On involves incorporating natural lighting such as skylights in the main room of the plant, where trucks dump the waste they collect. The roof of the building needs replacing, and skylights are energy efficient and practical for such a space, the students said.

Because this is a student exercise, the aspiring young architects themselves cannot actually put any design into effect, but they sure have got people interested and some ideas may be implemented.

Tom Fisher, dean of the College of Design, is in charge of this year’s Greenlight event.

“Greenlight is a student group, and they focus on one project a year,” Fisher said. “This year the project is the HERC burner.”

The students visited HERC to learn how it works before they brainstormed ways to improve its appearance. Most were impressed with the plant and irked about the massive amounts of packaging and other garbage that overflows from trash bins around and off campus that is never recycled.

According to Greenlight, the average American produces 4.4 pounds of garbage every day, which adds up to one ton or 1600 pounds of waste every year.

Carl Michaud, who works for Hennepin County’s Department of Environmental Services, said the county measured the concentration of chemicals in this steam and found it safe for all fans, staff and players at the ballpark. In June 2007, it released an environmental impact statement that concluded, “Health risks associated with HERC emissions are below EPA (Environmental Protection Agency) levels of concern.”

Michaud said Minnesotans recycle 46 percent of waste, burn 35 percent, and ship the rest to a landfill. Landfills are the most inefficient way of getting rid of waste and they are running out of space. Minnesota has established a goal to raise the percentage of recycling to 50 percent. Already, all tires in Minnesota are recycled, and HERC sorts metal for recycling during the waste processing. “The waste just doesn’t stop; it keeps coming,” Michaud said.

The Twins stadium inadvertently brought to light an issue that Americans, generally, like to ignore – waste. In this case, the most important thing is to make sure the fans and players won’t notice the waste; they have a game to enjoy.

Comments

Anonymous's picture

Why don’t they just dye

Why don’t they just dye the toxic smoke green?

Matty Lang's picture

It may be under "acceptable amounts" of emissions. . .

. . .but, the Covanta operation at HERC is hardly cutting edge technology. We need to be reducing, reusing and recycling rather than burning or landfilling garbage.

Smaller, distributed electricity and heat generation projects are an excellent asset to our communities, only if they are using clean and renewable resources. Garbage does not qualify as clean and it’s horribly in our worst interests to make it “renewable”, by creating incentives to waste.

Katy's picture

Additional Greenlight Proposals

In addition to proposing energy and aesthetic improvements to the HERC facility, greenlight also proposed strategies that target both the individual consumer as well as long term system improvements.

First one of greenlight’s goals is educating consumers that trash is not a renewable resource.
“Minnesota throws away over 1 million tons of recyclable material each year. The 1 million tons of material which could be recycled has an estimated value of $312 million dollars. It costs Minnesota $200 million to dispose of this material.” (http://recyclemoreminnesota.org/why/stats) That is a $512 million loss by burning this resource.

One proposal included using the stadium, a controlled environment, as a Zero waste model by using only recylcable and compotable products. This can both eliminate trash and educate thousands of citizens from around the entire state about being responsible with our waste.

Furthermore, the group looked long term proposing a “sunsetting” scheme for HERC that phases out burning this resource to become a waste sorting facility that eliminates landfill trash altogether.

gharri's picture

Day to day environmental help

I agree with Katy. High profile actions have their place, but we can all help the environment daily through watching what we do and how we do it. There are some great ideas on this thread:
http://digits.hrblock.com/ssDigits/digits.php?rType=1&sPath=1697&sNode=1...

Post new comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
CAPTCHA
This question is for testing whether you are a human visitor and to prevent automated spam submissions.
7 + 13 =
Solve this simple math problem and enter the result. E.g. for 1+3, enter 4.

Things People Say

Readers comment on theater at St. Thomas

“Foley folly” ... “Tragic mistake” ... “Disappointment by St. Thomas choice” ... “Money isn’t everything.” Comments on St. Thomas’s plans to close its 80-year-old Department of Theater and tear down the Foley Theater show a depth of sorrow and disappointment. MORE »